I bought this Acro gladly because it’s actually my favourite dinosaur and Carnegie has a great reputation. To my surprise, all this wasn’t enough, it displays great, it’s a durable, non-expensive toy but not exactly what one would expect from a famous company. Many pieces of the Carnegie line are not precisely about the details, they’re rough, but many are accurate in their simplicity. Nonetheless in this case they didn’t concentrate on interpreting the fossil evidence correctly, which is inexcusable; if Battat was able to make an exceptional Acrocanthosaurus more than 10 years ago, why not Carnegie?
The head is the first thing I find problematic. The real Acrocanthosaurus had long jaws, but this replica’s are just too short. On top of that, there’s an inexplicable lump on the snout. The result is a bland, generic looking theropod head.
There is another bothersome problem. Symmetry is absent in several parts: nostrils, legs, eyes, even belly.
They didn’t interpret the vertebral spines according to the most accepted theory (a hump covered with muscle instead of a sail) but the sail is not raised enough. The spines may not have been as high as the Spinosaurus, but they were quite pronounced, starting just where the skull ends. None of this is reflected on the end product. Even if it does stand on its own (I know at least mine does) the tail is just too close to the ground.
Carnegie dinosaurs often have strange limbs that aren’t naturally attached to the torso. This is no exception. The extremities are not massive enough; the hips are flattened (even sunken). This is specially frustrating, because there should be plenty of muscle. Mind you, this lack of muscle detail is generalized, except for the tail.
Nonetheless, it’s an eye-pleaser, I won’t deny that. Teeth and tongue look great, the fingers are finely sculpted, there’s a huge amount of skin detail, the colours and blending are nice as always (in this case, mostly grey and black, while the mouth is pink), the paint itself is quite resistent. I just hope in the future these guys will be more careful.
Source : http://dinosaurcollector.wordpress.com/2008/01/06/acrocanthosaurus-carnegie-collection-by-safari/
Popularity: 15% [?]
Viewed 1379 times by 522 viewers
